Calling in a Claim

We understand that being in the situation where you need to make a claim is hard enough, therefore we want to personally help you through the process. Please call us at let us do the hard work for you. Find your local office below:

(304) 347-8972 – South Charleston
(304) 757-6880 – Teays Valley
(304) 525-7050 – Lavalette
(304) 595-3155 – Glasgow
(304) 675-7036 – Point Pleasant


Calling in a Claim

After Hours Claims

If you need to make a claim after our business hours, we have listed several of our carrier contact numbers below. As an independent agent, we represent dozens of carriers, so if you don’t happen to see your policy carrier listed, please refer to your specific policy. 

800-642-1948 – Erie
800-638-8763 – Dairyland
800-852-5416 – Municipal Mutual
800-588-7400 – Encompass
800-332-3226 – Safeco
800-766-1853 – State Auto
800-444-1917 – Farmers & Mechanics

Garlow Insurance Carriers